Discussion: Illegal Immigration and Other Citizenship Issues

Status
Not open for further replies.

ShadowBoxing

Avenger
Joined
Sep 10, 2004
Messages
30,620
Reaction score
2
Points
31
Weigh in with your opinion

http://articles.news.aol.com/news/article.adp?id=20060518052609990015&ncid=NWS00010000000001


Bush Backs English as 'Common and Unifying'
Senate Immigration Bill Includes Language Amendments

WASHINGTON (May 19) - President George W. Bush supports two Senate proposals that English is the U.S. language and the "common and unifying language," White House spokesman Tony Snow said Friday.

"What the president has said all along is that he wants to make sure that people who become American citizens have a command of the English language," Snow said. "It's as simple as that."

The Senate on Thursday first voted 63-34 to make English the national language of the United States after lawmakers who led the effort said it would promote national unity.

But critics argued the move would prevent limited English speakers from getting language assistance required by an executive order signed by former President Bill Clinton. So the Senate then voted 58-39 on saying that English is the U.S.'s "common and unifying language."

Supporters agreed that both measures in the immigration bill currently under debate are largely symbolic. The bill has to be reconciled with a version passed by the House of Representatives before Bush signs it into law, probably by the end of the year.

"We are trying to make an assimilation statement," said Sen. Lindsey Graham, one of two dozen senators who voted Thursday for both proposals.

Sen. Jim Inhofe disputed charges that making English the national language was racist or aimed at Spanish speakers. Eleven Democrats joined Republicans in voting for his measure.

The provision makes exceptions for any language assistance already guaranteed by law, such as bilingual ballots required under the Voting Rights Act or court interpreters. It also requires immigrants seeking citizenship to demonstrate a "sufficient understanding of the English language for usage in every day life."

The Homeland Security Department is in the midst of redesigning the citizenship test and some groups have been concerned about efforts to make the test more difficult.

Sen. Ken Salazar offered the alternative. The only Republican to vote solely for Salazar's "common and unifying" language option was Sen. Pete Domenici of New Mexico, whose home state's constitution prohibits discrimination on basis of inability to speak, read or write English or Spanish.

Both provisions will be included in an immigration bill the Senate is expected to pass and send to conference with the House, where differences will be resolved.

Bush, who often peppers his speeches with Spanish words and phrases, had little to say about the Senate votes while visiting the Arizona-Mexico border. "The Senate needs to get the bill out," the president said.

Bush toured an unfortified section of the border in the Arizona desert Thursday, where he endorsed using fences and other barriers to cut down on illegal crossings. The Senate on Wednesday voted to put 370 miles of fences on the border.

Bush's border visit was part of his efforts to win over conservatives balking at his support for a path to citizenship for illegal immigrants and a new guest worker program.

Bush asked Congress for $1.9 billion Thursday to pay for 1,000 Border Patrol agents and the temporary deployment of up to 6,000 National Guard troops to states along the Mexican border.

Not a fan myself.
 
I am you have to know some English to try and become a citizen and if you have lived in America for the 8 years it takes to become a citizen and don't know English I don't think you can rightfully call yourself a citizen
 
I was also born in England and became an American Citizen so i am not ignorant to foreigners struggles
 
If they really think that making English the OFFICIAL language of the United States will serve as a unifying thing, they're delusional. I find it ironic that Bush is pushing for this when he can barely speak English himself, actually. I love how when the approval ratings are low or there's things going on that Bush doesn't want people to pay attention to (like the things happening in Iraq) that he and his cronies drudge up non-issues like gay marriage and immigration for people to fixate on instead.

jag
 
I think english should be the official language, and should be a requirement for obtaining citizenship. If I have pass out from a stroke or something, then the potential good samaritain should be able to call an ambulance in English.
 
giggs11uk said:
I am you have to know some English to try and become a citizen and if you have lived in America for the 8 years it takes to become a citizen and don't know English I don't think you can rightfully call yourself a citizen

I wish you had learned english before you became a citizen.:D
 
Liquid Snake said:
wait, so illegals are being allowed to stay?

Illegals are not being "allowed" anything.
the idea of deporting all of them was a pipe dream for some, and a distraction for all, it was NEVER going to happen, they are going to put some triple walls on some sections of the border (rolleyes infity) in the end, things will stay the same.
 
Aren't there more important things than what language the country decides to make official?
 
jaguarr said:
If they really think that making English the OFFICIAL language of the United States will serve as a unifying thing, they're delusional. I find it ironic that Bush is pushing for this when he can barely speak English himself, actually. I love how when the approval ratings are low or there's things going on that Bush doesn't want people to pay attention to (like the things happening in Iraq) that he and his cronies drudge up non-issues like gay marriage and immigration for people to fixate on instead.

jag

I agree.
 
Also, what exactly are the requirements to becoming a citizen? WHat are the tests? How does a foreigner become a citizen?
 
SickBoy said:
Also, what exactly are the requirements to becoming a citizen? WHat are the tests? How does a foreigner become a citizen?

Yeah, I wondering that too?

In Canada you must speak English or French if you want to become a citizen.
 
I think it is important to learn the language of the country in which you wish to live. And i think if immigrants actually submerse themselves in our culture, they are bound to pick stuff up. I hear it all the time: if you are in a foreign country, especially for a long period of time, you naturally pick up the language. I can see how this wouldn't always happen (i.e. mexican immigrants settling into heavily-populated mexican areas where they could get by without learning much English), but overall i don't think it would be too hard for immigrants to learn English if given enough time and with special programs to help them learn it.

If i wanted to live in a foreign country (which i have thought about), i would WANT to learn the language. Overall it would make things a lot easier for me. But i would want to be allowed time to learn it, and not have to live up to impossible standards to become a legal citizen. What are Americas standards and requirements for becoming a legal citizen? I am very curious. I will look it up when i have more time.

However, the difficulty of learning a new language depends in part on the individuals particular abilities, whether they already speak multiple languages, what language they are coming from, etc.

Whether this would be truly "unifying"... i dont know.
 
Yes, the citizens of the States will become unified when English is the official language :rolleyes:
 
SickBoy said:
I think it is important to learn the language of the country in which you wish to live. And i think if immigrants actually submerse themselves in our culture, they are bound to pick stuff up. I hear it all the time: if you are in a foreign country, especially for a long period of time, you naturally pick up the language. I can see how this wouldn't always happen (i.e. mexican immigrants settling into heavily-populated mexican areas where they could get by without learning much English), but overall i don't think it would be too hard for immigrants to learn English if given enough time and with special programs to help them learn it.

If i wanted to live in a foreign country (which i have thought about), i would WANT to learn the language. Overall it would make things a lot easier for me. But i would want to be allowed time to learn it, and not have to live up to impossible standards to become a legal citizen. What are Americas standards and requirements for becoming a legal citizen? I am very curious. I will look it up when i have more time.

However, the difficulty of learning a new language depends in part on the individuals particular abilities, whether they already speak multiple languages, what language they are coming from, etc.

Whether this would be truly "unifying"... i dont know.
what culture:confused:
 
Addendum said:
Yes, the citizens of the States will become unified when English is the official language :rolleyes:

Ha. Yeah, the unification thing is ridiculous. I think people should eventually learn enough of the language to get by in the country in which they living, but i don't think we need to call English the "official language" of america and force everyone to become fluent. I support cultural diversity.

I don't want America to turn into a super-isolated, close-minded, egotistic country. Oh, wait...:(
 
in my opinion this is one step closer to a USA where even the legal immigrants are treated as second class citizens because they speak "funny".. "Oh, Jesus of Nazareth! Go learn some english, you ****ing Brit:mad:"
 
Corinthian™ said:
what culture:confused:

you know, hang out around mostly english speakers in order to pick up the language. I guess they wouldn't really have to submerse themselves in white culture to do that... but at least try to associate with english speakers enough to pick up some english. Spending all your time in a community dominated by your own nationality makes it easier to get by without learning the country's language.
 
hell this was a no-brainer...u should learn-speak english if u live in america
 
SickBoy said:
you know, hang out around mostly english speakers in order to pick up the language. I guess they wouldn't really have to submerse themselves in white culture to do that... but at least try to associate with english speakers enough to pick up some english. Spending all your time in a community dominated by your own nationality makes it easier to get by without learning the country's language.
I meant that the culture of America is about having different languages, different nationalities and different people with only one thing in common. They all are American.

Making USA a nation of one language is actually destroying what the USA stands for. The entire world, but even better
 
Also in my opinion, they are doing this because they don't want to have spanish as the top languge to be speak
 
Corinthian™ said:
in my opinion this is one step closer to a USA where even the legal immigrants are treated as second class citizens because they speak "funny".. "Oh, Jesus of Nazareth! Go learn some english, you ****ing Brit:mad:"

Good point. a lot of times when Americans talk to people who don't speak English fluently, they think of them as being stupid. I don't know if there is any way around this. Most immigrants wouldn't be able to learn the language completely fluently unless they are very young and coming over with their parents and grow up around english speakers.

People need to be sympathetic to those who do not know the language 100% and try to communicate as best they can. It doesn't hurt for Americans to pick up a little spanish too.
 
Mr Sparkle said:
Illegals are not being "allowed" anything.
the idea of deporting all of them was a pipe dream for some, and a distraction for all, it was NEVER going to happen, they are going to put some triple walls on some sections of the border (rolleyes infity) in the end, things will stay the same.
I thought bush was giving them amnesty?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"