Stewie Griffin said:
That is just ABSURD. One of thee dumbest comments I have ever seen.
Sigh, I won't even try to explain... Amazing.
Ok, no I will. I respect Griffin. I've read some of your posts before, and you seem like a good poster. I'm not sure why you'd go and insult me, but then again maybe you didn't intend to, or you were in a bad mood. Who knows.
So, i'll try to.
Look at howl's moving castle. Or, um, any other miyazaki, or the first ghost in the shell. There are painting, and drawing in there. When Sophie's character in Howl's moving castle opens the castle's window to look outside, we see the land they are in. It's all so beautifully draw, or painted (there's some 3D hidden underneath also, but 2D is painted on it, masking it).
And the viewers go "holy crap, what a wonder!". Or something like that.
Same with many of the greatest animated movies (mostly the japanese ones, actually. Though, there are still many beautiful american one, but they, imo, never achieve Oshii, Takahata or Miyazaki's sense of wonders).
But then you go look at a 3D movie. Let's take the best of them for exemple. The pixar movies (they are easily the most well done of the 3D bunch, and, imo, the betters).
In incredible, when we get on the island, the first thing I though was "woah, that's so well done, I could swear it's real". And while it felt real (well, mostly), real looking didn't make me go into a state of wonder, but rather of intrigue. I was amaze not by the movie's beauty, but by how well it duplicated the real world.
Same with nearly every 3D movies. The problem with 3D, ain't the medium. It CAN produce beauty. But it cost a lot, and people still aren't sure what they should do with it. So many possibilities. And so they often go with the most real looking style. Sure, the main character are deformed, but the backgrounds all look real (or at least try to).
2D's simplicity is his main weapon. I think, that might be one of the reasons why.
But 3D CAN do wonders. In the right hands. In the gaming world, the industry is getting VERY diverse. And we get games like Ico and shadow of the colossus, that looks like nothing we usually see. And it's a world of beauty. Now THAT'S how you try something.
Same thing in ghost in the shell 2: Innocence. Oshii's a genius. The characters are in 2D, but nearly everything else is in 3D.
And when you get at the middle of the movie, you are treated to a parade, nearly all in 3D. And it's got a style of his own. And my god it's fantastic!
3D CAN be beautiful. But, imo, it hasn't been used well. And so, 2D usually looks so much more beautiful in animated movies.