Saw this today and, shockingly, I think this was the best episode of the entire season. (of the ones I saw.) It had good action, it didn't seem to loiter too much, and had good emotional moments, esp from Skarsten. That woman is a
delight!
Was it a 10? No. It was a good 7. I would have enjoyed it more if Ryan said to Kate, 'you take the Batsuit, I found my own power now,' and we finally got Kate Kane back as Batwoman. But since I knew
that wasn't going to happen...
Anyway, this Gotham being ripped apart was the visage of Gotham that we should have been seeing throughout the first and second season. Maybe toned down a little, but this sort of anarchy was something we were promised at the start and was barely delivered on.
Lucas finding the suit his father made for him, and based on his childish drawings, was done very well. I was suddenly all for him putting it on.
Them using Snake-bite to jar Kate's memories was good too. It's supposed to make you relive happy memories with better outcomes, and that was a good way to draw her out. Both Kate and Alice going over the bridge was a neat return to the original accident, and I'm glad that Alice got to say goodbye to Ocean, at least in some way. And then she was so happy when Kate called her Beth...
And then the show just
shat all over it by having her arrested right after. Um, we are outside of city limits, a city that is being torn apart by riots and the police have the man-power to send some people out to check out a fight on a deserted bridge..? Okay...
Once again, Beth gets the shortest end of the stick.
Recognizing that we were not going to get Kate back as Batwoman, what I would have preferred was she and Beth leaving the city together. Let Kate recover, and get Beth away from everything that required her to be 'Alice.' That would have been a good, final end for the Kane sisters, to just ride off into the night together.
But no. After seeing Beth once by the river, Kate doesn't mention her again and does not go to see her before she leaves. Heck, I would have been fine if a final scene had Kate breaking Beth out of Arkham, but we got nothing from the yin and yang of the first season.
And now Alice knows (somehow) that Ryder's mother might still be alive... Where's that headbanging emoji? Oh, there it is!
The entire season (from the episodes I saw) was a mishmash that shouldn't have happened. I can blame RR for leaving, but the real reason it just felt off the rails from the start was Dries and whoever else decided that just recasting Kate Kane would somehow be the harder course to take. Dries described that as being too much like a 'soap opera,' and yet the entire season just felt like that. Like they were scrambling to shoe-horn in an entirely new actress into an entirely new character while also taking the heart of it, Kate Kane, out of it.
Ho hum, grumble grumble grumble, and all that! The first season was a good ride, the second a waste of time, for me anyway, and the third, maybe I'll catch it in reruns.
And who knows. Give it a year or two and maybe someone can reboot the entire thing on another network. HBO Max, you listening..? Netflix? Peacock..?