SuperFerret
King of the Urban Jungle
- Joined
- Apr 2, 2004
- Messages
- 33,639
- Reaction score
- 6
- Points
- 58
"Why is the sky blue?" "Who cares? Get on with your day."
A friendly reminder to our users, please make sure your account is safe. Make sure you update your password and have an active email address to recover or change your password.
JAK®;19893346 said:Good god, all I'm saying is that I expected it to look bigger and it didn't. And now you're accusing me of being the downfall of human civilisation?
"Why is the sky blue?" "Who cares? Get on with your day."
You're not getting it are you?
Yeah, I got it. Your implying that the "why" behind the optical illusion is as irrelevant as why the sky is blue. I do not consider the "why" behind anything to be irrelelvant. I may not think about why everything is the way it is, but I don't consider the reason behind something un-important. It was people asking these questions for thousands of years that give you the ability to forget about the "why" and pass it off as unimportant. Had humans not asked why we would still believe the tides are caused by the god of the sea and that the sun circles us and a number of other superstitious and flawed ideas that were holding us back. We wouldn't have the math or any other form of science that allows us to be what we are today or accomplish the things we have.
And yet, for day to day life, many "why"s don't matter. Like "Why is the sky blue?"
JAK®;19893527 said:The point is, I expected the moon to look larger, and thought that it had looked bigger before. I was told "the moon didn't actually get larger those other times, it's an optical illusion"
My point is that's interesting, but doesn't address the disappointment I have now, because it still looked bigger those times. If instead he explained "the moon wasn't supposed to look bigger this time" I would've accepted that.
SF is acting like a stereotypical ignorant American
Ask a 5 year old to tell you why something is the way it is. They won't go into the technical details but they will do their best to tell you why. Kids eat this mundane stuff up. At that age they are like sponges. To them this mundane stuff is like candy. They want to know why everything is the way it is. It's only as we get older that we forget this stuff, and find it boring when really its our boring day to day lives that are mundane.
You kind of implied it with the Blue Sky thing
Am I? Because if you know me, you'll know that I'm not ignorant. Ask those that know me, they'll tell you that I'm actually quite intelligent. And it's because I was gifted with intelligence that I say this: academia is full of those who wish to show off their "superior" intelligence, by over explaining things that, while good to know and important for the furthering of scientific knowledge, don't really have any bearing on the subject at hand.
Would you like to be at a barbecue with me and have me explain the entire digestive process and my biological need for sustenance, when a "Man, I'm hungry" would suffice?
There's knowing why the sky is blue and not caring, there's not knowing why the sky is blue and not caring, and there's knowing why the sky is blue and letting everyone else know that you know. One is smart, the other is stupid, and the third is being a pompous ass.
And that's why I like children. They're open to everything and have a thirst for knowledge, and unfortunately as they age many will become ignorant and close-minded, but that's not what we're talking about here.