Sorry about the delay, spent the weekend at my girlfriend's and though I
could use her computer I obviously couldn't care less.
CFlash said:
Man! I dunno if I hate you or not. I love A.I. as well... I thought I was the only one!
Dude, don't even get me started on A.I.
I totally lost track of how many times I had to defend that movie from trolls who think the ending is gay or whatever. Actually, when I mention the ending is one of my favorite parts of the movie, people usually think I'm insane.
CFlash said:
But, I also did like Hook... a lot!
That's ok, bud. Nobody's perfect.
CFlash said:
And The Terminal... and Shrek... and almost everything else you cite.
But you have to admit The Terminal is kind of overly sentimental (especially in the second half) and Shrek pushes it's message and jokes too crudely (almost desperately). Even if you like those movies. Even if you laughed at Shrek farting for the 50th time.
CFlash said:
I can see Evolution being garbage (tho it's not any worse than Armageddon... and it's more fun than that craptitude)....
Lol, at least Evolution
knows it's a comedy, right?
(Armageddon is funnier, though.)
CFlash said:
And to answer your question: I watched Goonies just last month. Watched it with my daughter. It's one of the few movies (like Pulp Fiction funnily) that I can watch over and over and over again.
Yeah... I loved it as a kid, and I probably should have refrained (sp?) myself from watching it again as an adult.
The spell was completely broken. That movie is poorly directed, poorly acted, and I could come up with a better adventure in 5 minutes (when I was like twelve). It was as exciting as watching my grandma watch a soap-opera.
CFlash said:
I can see the highbrow intent of your Top 20 list. It reminds me of the Approval Matrix segment of New York magazine. Yes... some (all?) are masterpieces. But, the snob-appeal is a little too over the top for me.
Whoa, dude. You completely lost me there. I was gaining respect for you, and then you come up and...
Now, seriously, that list is
far from being an example of film-snobbishness.
Let's see, we have in first place "The World Of Apu", a very straightforward quasi-neorealistic tale, something
anyone could relate to. A story about death and family told with devastating simplicity and without a hint of ego (also the third part of a trilogy, but that's irrelevant).
In second place we have "His Girl Friday", a very straightforward hawksian screwball comedy, nothing really "difficult" here as long as you can keep up with the speed-of-light dialogue.
In third place we have "2001" a.k.a. One Of The Most Overrated Movies Of All Time According To CFlash, which is my all-time favorite sci-fi incidentally, and I'm sure you've noticed I love sci-fi etc. Really, this movie has so much atmosphere and mind****ing I wish I could erase it from my mind and watch it again for the first time. Over and over.
But now we're getting closer to the fim-snob end of the spectrum; in fourth place we have "The Rules Of The Game", a movie that presents itself every ****ing time a group of critics decide to produce a consensual "all-time top 10", along with "Citizen Kane" and the like. But have you seen it?
It's one of the ten best movies of all time.
Seriously.
But wait. In fifth place we have "In A Lonely Place", a very straightforward drama/noir starring Bogart (who doesn't like Bogart?). No snobbishness here, as this isn't even usually praised by critics as the best movie with Bogart, or the best Nicholas Ray movie, or even the best movie of 1950 (a year that had "Sunset Blvd."
and "All About Eve"!). So it's clearly a personal choice.
See where this is going? The list also features "The Birds" (not usually considered the best Hitchcock) and "Kiss Me Deadly", which were both very "commercial" movies back in the day (though both have a strong subtext about that eras paranoia, so I guess you could argue they are snobbish choices because of that). And so on, and so forth. "After Hours"? Come on. If you're into 80s' nostalgia, there's no better movie. **** The Goonies in my opinion.
The few really artsy stuff in my list (Stalker, Sans Soleil, Woman In The Dunes, Songs From The Second Floor) are all movies I really love, movies that really affected me (though I probably should remove "Stalker", as I'm not so much into Tarkovsky these days). I didn't put them there to sound smart or anything (as you kind of implied).
Cflash said:
I'm more of a B-Movie fan. Big fan at that. I'd pick Evil Dead over half of those movies on your list. ;-)
I like Evil Dead, it's a good horror movie, but I prefer the in-your-face slapstick of Army of Darkness. Raimi is a genius at that. You know who else is a genius? George A. Romero. Night Of The Living Dead = my second favorite movie of 1968. I like P. Jackson's "Braindead", too. I even own the DVD. Its hysterical.
Not a big fan of B-Movies, though. Most of them are just too crappy to be enjoyable, IMO.
CFlash said:
P.S.
A.I. is one of the most underrated movies of all time IMHO.
Yes.
CFlash said:
And 2001 is one of the most overrated.
No.
CFlash said:
(I enjoyed the book tho).
Never read it. I heard it explains too much. Bleh.
CFlash said:
Kubrick and Spielberg should have done more movies together IMO.
;-)
Kubrick should have made more movies, period.