I just watched this on Prime.
I mean, I didn't hate it. I found it compelling and interesting enough that I went along with it even if I wasn't exactly engaged or enthralled by it. There are moments where the filmmaking really hits--and then those moments just get streeeetched out for another five minutes or whatever and you lose the effect. But the film still kind of dangles you along.
The design and cinematography were cool for the most part, the editing of certain sequences definitely has its own modern dance rhythm thing going, but towards the end it all goes very heavy-handed and schlocky and the weird frame rate shots in the red light were just ugly. I think Luca was going for hypnotic or something but it just feels rough. Yorke's score had its moments, particularly the main theme used with the Volk dance, but there were other times where the score was kind of egregiously distracting and not enhancing what we were seeing. Really think there should have been no Yorke singing until the credits.
It's definitely a movie that has more than a few groaner moments. I get why people call it "pretentious," but I don't know. lt's a pretty obvious movie in a lot of ways, it just makes a lot of wacky choices about how to tell its story and tries to stuff multiple other stories in at awkward angles. Like many modern films, its plot is needlessly complicated. Think back to how much time we spent with you-know-who stealing the you-know-what and giving it to one of Tilda Swinton's characters and then what happens with that. There is so much like that in the movie. If God is in the details he's wondering how to get out of them in this flick, because these details be a hot mess. Maybe that's the point, a literal hell of storytelling. Well okay then.
The final shot before the credits was a total WTF lol moment for me, not because it's some bonkers shot but because it's so sentimental and irrelevant to the vast majority of the movie that I simply had to laugh that Luca thought that THAT should be the final shot. Like he basically could not figure out what he wanted the last shot to be and picked some random idea out of a hat. The post-credits shot is almost as bad.