Who Knows Batman is Bruce? (Very rough draft of a master list)

[celldog]

Here's the revised and expanded Second Draft:

The Master List

Aaron Langstrom (Son of Man-Bat. His knowledge of the secret was established in “Gotham Knights #45”)
Alexander Luthor (Dead. Apparently learned during the long period when he had nothing better to do in the “paradise dimension” than play peeping tom, watching events in the Post-Crisis DCU)
Alfred Pennyworth (Different versions have been told of how he learned, but either he was already working for Bruce when the Batman identity was created, or else he was hired later and quickly found out)
The Appelaxians (Were able to find and invade the Batcave and capture Batman in “JLA: Year One” based on information gleaned from the Martian Manhunter’s secret files. Of course, I don’t know if the general plot of “JLA: Year One” is still in continuity in the Post-IC DCU. The roster of founding members of the JLA has retroactively been changed again, after all)
The Atom II (Ray Palmer. His ex-wife Jean Loring definitely knew in “Identity Crisis #7” that Bruce is Batman; presumably she heard it from him – I’ll go back and reread IC later to double-check on how much Ray appeared to know)
Azrael (Jean Paul Valley. Learned during the “Sword of Azrael” miniseries)
Bane (Figured it out very quickly in “Knightfall” after looking at Bruce Wayne’s body language)
Batgirl III (Cassandra Cain. Learned when, for the first time, she saw Batman in his role as Bruce Wayne during the “Bruce Wayne: Murderer?” event. She recognized his body language instantly)
Benedict Asp (Learned in “Legends of the Dark Knight #61.” Then he died)
Bird (Now believed dead. Bane told him in “Knightfall”)
Black Canary II (Dinah Lance. Her current knowledge was recently confirmed in the “JLA: Crisis of Conscience” story arc, although a few years earlier, in “Bruce Wayne: Murderer?” she clearly didn’t know Bruce was Batman)
Black Lightning (Jefferson Pierce. Learned in “Batman and the Outsiders #13.” Still knew in a comic published in 1996, so I’m figuring that the other Outsiders from #13 still know as well, despite the other retcons of COIE and Zero Hour and so forth)
Blue Beetle II (Ted Kord. Dead. I think he learned in “Countdown to Infinite Crisis” and then promptly got himself killed)
Booster Gold I (Michael Carter. Dead)
Cain (David Cain. Not sure just when he realized)
Carleton LeHah (Learned during the “Sword of Azrael” miniseries)
Catwoman I (Selina Kyle. Bruce voluntarily told her during “Hush” – we don’t know for sure if she already knew or suspected; we can fill in the blanks any way we please!)
Chronos I (David Clinton. Found out the secret IDs of Batman and several other JLAers a long time ago, according to an “Identity Crisis” retcon. Then got mindwiped by Zatanna. Then Despero recently helped him rediscover those memories in “JLA: Crisis of Conscience.” Then they got wiped out (or suppressed, or whatever) by Zatanna all over again . . . until further notice?)
The Crime Doctor (Bradford Thorne. Dead. Learned in his first appearance, in “Detective Comics #494.” One issue later, he went into a coma from mercury poisoning. Years later, he recovered. Since that time, I gather that no Post-Crisis story has ever clearly told us that he did – or didn’t – remember Batman’s identity after he awoke.)
Damian (Batman’s newly-introduced long-lost son. Presumably he has known all his life, thanks to his mommy, Talia.)
Deacon Blackfire (Dead. Learned during the miniseries “The Cult.” That mini has reportedly been erased from continuity, however.)
Deadman (Boston Brand. Since he is normally an invisible and intangible ghost who can go anywhere and spy on anyone, it would be very easy for him to learn any secret identity if he got interested enough to bother, and he demonstrated his knowledge of where to find the Batcave (right under Wayne Manor, natch!) in “Batman #530”)
Deathstroke the Terminator (Slade Wilson. Probably learned from Terra I around the time of “The Judas Contract.” Or, even if Terra only knew Dick Grayson’s real name after she became a trusted member of the Titans, which is the interpretation that Denny O’Neil later preferred from the mid-90s onward regarding how much Dick ever shared with his fellow Titans about the Batman Family’s secrets, that would be still enough of a lead for a smart guy like Slade to figure out the rest of it himself, later)
Deathwing (Comes from an alternate future timeline, now defunct, in which he had been brainwashed by the Time Trapper so he could pass himself off as Dick Grayson, the Nightwing of “ten years from now.” Evidently he was well-briefed on all Titans lore and Dick Grayson’s biography in particular, including the role of Bruce Wayne/Batman in his life, in order to carry the role with conviction)
Despero (Restored various suppressed memories to the Secret Society of Super-Villains in the “JLA: Crisis of Conscience” story arc . . . and as it turned out, those memories included the knowledge that Batman is Bruce Wayne (not to mention several other JLA secret IDs). In the process, Despero apparently learned this secret himself (if he didn’t already know? He is a telepath, after all). At the end of the arc, he was subdued by Zatanna’s magic and allegedly was going to be taken off to Oa for containment, but – as far as I can tell – he still had all that knowledge of secret IDs inside his head. The other villains whom he had helped to regain these memories included: Chronos, Felix Faust, Floronic Man, Matter Master, Star Sapphire, The Wizard)
Doc Creasey (Dead. Bought the secret of Batman’s identity from “The Nobody” in “Shadow of the Bat #13.” One of Joker’s henchmen killed Creasey before he could make any use of his new knowledge)
The Elongated Man (Ralph Dibny. His knowledge was recently confirmed in the “JLA: Crisis of Conscience” arc)
Faith (According to recent issues of “JLA Classified”)
Felix Faust (Found out the secret IDs of Batman and several other JLAers a long time ago, according to an “Identity Crisis” retcon. Then got mindwiped by Zatanna. Then Despero recently helped him rediscover those memories in “JLA: Crisis of Conscience.” Then they got wiped out (or suppressed, or whatever) by Zatanna all over again . . . until further notice?)
Flash III (Wally West)
The Floronic Man (Jason Woodrue. Found out the secret IDs of Batman and several other JLAers a long time ago, according to an “Identity Crisis” retcon. Then got mindwiped by Zatanna. Then Despero recently helped him rediscover those memories in “JLA: Crisis of Conscience.” Then they got wiped out (or suppressed, or whatever) by Zatanna all over again . . . until further notice?)
Fritz (A thug who worked for Benedict Asp. Learned in “Legends of the Dark Knight #61.” Then he died)
Geo-Force (Brion Markov. Learned in “Batman and the Outsiders #13”)
Green Arrow I (Oliver Queen. Already knew by the time of a conversation with Batman in “Green Arrow #5” (the third series of that name). I’m told that it is far from clear just when and how he found out in the modern continuity, however)
Green Lantern #whatever (Hal Jordan, formerly known as Parallax, and later as The Spectre II. His knowledge was confirmed during the recent “JLA: Crisis of Conscience” story arc)
Halo (Violet Hunter. Learned in “Batman and the Outsiders #13”)
Harbinger (Lyla, the former assistant to the Monitor. Had access to information about everyone interesting)
Harold Allnut (Dead. Presumably found out shortly after Batman met him and took him home to the Batcave in “Batman #458.”)
Hawkman (Carter Hall. His knowledge was recently confirmed in the “JLA: Crisis of Conscience” arc)
Hawkgirl (Kendra Saunders)
Henri Ducard (One of Bruce’s old teachers; he deduced the secret in the “Blind Justice” story arc, which has allegedly been erased from continuity, which would certainly explain why I don’t remember ever seeing Ducard make any use of this knowledge in any subsequent appearances in other comics)
Hourman III, from the 853rd Century (Dead. The secret was also known to a bunch of his friends from the Justice Legion who appeared in the “DC One Million” event, because the identities of modern-era heroes are all available in public records in the 853rd century)
Hugo Strange (kinda-sorta-sometimes thinks he knows, but -- as far as I can tell in the modern continuity -- has never actually proven it for sure. For instance, he's never captured Batman and then ripped off his cowl to reveal the face of Bruce Wayne underneath)
Hush (Thomas “Tommy” Elliot. We learned at the end of “Hush” that he had learned it from Riddler in a conversation we never saw, before that story arc even started)
Ion (Kyle Rayner, formerly Green Lantern #whatever. Learned in “JLA #50.”)
Jack Drake (Dead)
Jason Todd (Formerly Robin II, later The Red Hood II. More recently Nightwing #whatever -- I’m not sure if he still uses that name today, and I’ve lost track of what the numbering would be, given that Power Girl and Cheyenne Freemont have also been using that name in OYL stories)
Jean Loring (Refers to Batman as “Bruce” in “Identity Crisis #7”)
Jeannie Bowen (In the “Blind Justice” story arc, which has allegedly been erased from continuity)
Katana (Tatsu Yamashiro. Learned in “Batman and the Outsiders #13”)
Kathy Sutton (Wife of Red Tornado II. Demonstrates her knowledge in “Justice League of America #1” (the newest series; the one that just started a couple of months ago)
Lady Shiva (Nightwing commented that she was on the list of enemies who definitely knew, in a conversation he had with Robin III (Tim) in “Gotham Knights #8.” I don’t think we know just when or how she found out)
Leslie Thompkins (In the current continuity, an old friend of the family who found out soon after Bruce invented his new identity.)
Lois Lane (Probably learned from her husband Clark, but I’m not sure just when)
Man-Bat (Kirk Langstrom. His knowledge was established in “Gotham Knights #45”)
Martian Manhunter (J’onn J’onnz. May have learned by telepathic prying in “JLA: Year One” if that is still in continuity)
Matches Malone (Dead. But he had somehow figured it out before he died, according to a letter column in “Detective Comics #765”)
Maxwell Lord (Dead. Apparently learned the secret from Brother Eye, or perhaps by telepathic prying?)
Metamorpho (Rex Mason. Learned in “Batman and the Outsiders #13”)
Neron (Can see anywhere. Visited the Batcave in “Underworld Unleashed #2”)
Nightwing I (Dick Grayson, formerly Robin I and Batman III)
"The Nobody" (Dead. A convenient label for a homeless man, real name unknown, who learned Batman’s identity and then was killed by the man he sold it to (Doc Creasey), in “Shadow of the Bat #13”)
Nomoz (Learned during the “Sword of Azrael” miniseries)
Nyssa Raatko (AKA Ra’s al Ghul II. Dead. Demonstrated her knowledge of Bruce’s secret in the “Death and the Maidens” miniseries. I don’t recall that we ever learned how she knew)
Oracle (Barbara Gordon, the former Batgirl I. She’s known for a long, long time, but I’m not certain exactly when and how she found out. I don’t know if there’s ever been a Post-Crisis flashback story that gave us the current “official details.” In Pre-Crisis Earth-1 continuity, Bruce told her voluntarily in the 70s, then her knowledge later got mindwiped in an incredibly bad story, then in “Detective Comics #526” Gerry Conway delicately retconned that by simply having Babs Gordon (still Batgirl I at the time) casually tell Dick that she had deduced their secret identities months earlier – but, when she realized how uptight they were about their privacy, she tactfully permitted them to think they had managed to throw her off the scent. As far as I know, Conway’s version can still be considered valid in the Post-Crisis DCU, unless a newer story has explicitly rewritten the details of how Babs found out? If you know of such a story, tell me!)
Owlman (Thomas Wayne, member of the Crime Syndicate of America, on the Earth in the Antimatter Universe. Introduced in Grant Morrison’s “JLA: Earth-2.” Once he visited the regular DCU Earth, it was a foregone conclusion that he’d figure it out. Since he is effectively Batman’s “evil twin” from a parallel universe, as soon as he became aware of Batman’s existence he couldn’t help knowing that Batman must be a member of the filthy rich Wayne family of Gotham City, which would narrow the field down to one possible suspect, right?)
The Phantom Stranger (He seems virtually omniscient. In “Batman/Phantom Stranger” he dropped in on Bruce Wayne and his conversation made it clear he knew)
Plastic Man (Eel O’Brian. Learned in “JLA #50”)
Ra's al Ghul (Dead. Already knew the secret, from behind-the-scenes detective work, when he made his debut way back when in “Batman #232.” At least some of his Ubus and other hirelings have also known, when it suited his purpose to let them know)
Red Tornado II (Not sure when he learned in modern continuity, but probably before “JLA: Crisis of Conscience” when Batman is working to repair him in the Batcave)
Riddler (Edward Nigma. At the very end of “Hush,” revealed that he had already figured it all out, behind the scenes, before “Hush” ever started. Now, however, he appears to have totally forgotten – or else is pretending he forgot – in Dini’s current run on “Detective Comics.”)
Robin III (Tim Drake. Revealed that he had already known for several years before he ever got around to mentioning his knowledge to Dick Grayson and Bruce Wayne during the story arc “A Lonely Place of Dying” in 1989)
Roy Kane (Dead. Learned and died in the “Blind Justice” story arc, which has allegedly been erased from continuity)
Ruby (Apparently her real first name. Dead. A female criminal who broke into the Batcave in “Batman #577” and learned Batman’s secret identity and then conveniently died by the end of the issue, as did her accomplices, “Ruby’s Brother” and “Sneaky Pete.”)
Ruby's Brother (Dead. We never knew his real name. See entry for “Ruby”)
Sasha Bordeaux (Learned in “Detective Comics #756” when she found one of Bruce’s costumes)
Sentinel (Alan Scott, formerly the Golden Age Green Lantern. Showed that he knew in “Detective Comics #784”)
Sherlock Holmes (Showed that he had deduced it independently in “Detective Comics #572.” As far as I know, there’s no reason to think that’s been retconned)
Shondra Kinsolving (Learned in “Legends of the Dark Knight #61.” Then she regressed to early childhood, mentally, and was placed in a sanitarium. In “Hush” there was a brief reference to the vague idea that eventually “she got better.” She may or may not remember anything about Batman’s secrets now; who knows?)
Silver St. Cloud (Learned during the Steve Englehart/Marshall Rogers run on “Detective Comics” that is reprinted in the TPB “Batman: Strange Apparitions”)
Sneaky Pete (Dead. See entry for “Ruby”)
The Spectre I (Jim Corrigan. Dead and gone, now. Visited the Batcave in “Batman #541.”)
The Spectre III (Crispus Allen. Apparently learned in #1 of his own series)
Spoiler (Stephanie Brown, AKA Robin IV just before she died. I think she would have learned Batman’s identity when she became the new Robin, or possibly sooner?)
Star Sapphire IV (Deborah Camille Darnell. Dead. Found out the secret IDs of Batman and several other JLAers a long time ago, according to an “Identity Crisis” retcon. Then got mindwiped by Zatanna. Then Despero recently helped her rediscover those memories in “JLA: Crisis of Conscience.” Then they got wiped out (or suppressed, or whatever) by Zatanna all over again . . . until further notice?)
Superboy-Prime (Clark Kent of Earth-Prime, which is supposed to be “our Earth.” Presumably he knew from a very early age, thanks to comic books, TV shows, etc.)
Supergirl #whatever (Kara Zor-El, the Rebooted Version)
Superman (Clark Kent, Kal-El)
Supernova (Established in "52")
The Synaptic Kid (Only appeared in “Detective Comics #633.” Learned Batman’s identity telepathically, then – after a very confusing story – apparently ended up in a comatose condition with a mental breakdown, as a result of the shocking experience of messing around inside the complexities of Batman’s head without an invitation to be there. Let this be a lesson to us all . . .)
Talia
Trogg (Bane told him in “Knightfall”)
Tsunetomo (Dead. One of Bruce Wayne’s martial arts teachers. Recognized Batman’s fighting style in “Detective Comics Annual #3”)
Waverider (Learned all sorts of secrets, including Batman’s identity, when he was examining the possible futures of different heroes during the “Armageddon 2001” event in 1991)
White Martians (According to a statement made in the “JLA: New World Order” story arc, there are 78 of them. In the “JLA: Terror Incognita” story arc, it became clear that with their telepathy and all that, they definitely knew Batman’s secret identity, among others)
The Wizard (William I. Zard. Found out the secret IDs of Batman and several other JLAers a long time ago, according to an “Identity Crisis” retcon. Then got mindwiped by Zatanna. Then Despero recently helped him rediscover those memories in “JLA: Crisis of Conscience.” Then they got wiped out (or suppressed, or whatever) by Zatanna all over again . . . until further notice?)
Wonder Woman I (Diana. Apparently it is not crystal-clear just when she learned)
Zatanna (Zatanna Zatara. Her knowledge of his identity was recently confirmed during the “JLA: Crisis of Conscience” story arc when she visited the Batcave and called him “Bruce” while trying to apologize for mindwiping him many years ago (as previously revealed in a retcon flashback in “Identity Crisis”). She offered to do anything she possibly could to make it up to him, and Batman listened to her speech and then simply told her to leave. (Considering that he didn’t hit her, file criminal charges or a civil lawsuit against her, scream obscenities at her, or suggest she go mindwipe herself and her former co-conspirators to balance the scales by removing their memories of his secrets this time around, I thought he handled it rather well.))
Zombie (Bane told him in “Knightfall”)

(By the way, the notes at the bottom of the first draft still apply. They explain some of the choices I made in who to leave off, for instance.)

Geeez.........for a guy who dresses in black, wears a cowl, hides in shadows, only comes out at night, lurks in shadows, lives on the outside of town and works in a cave, a whole lot of people (enemies included) know who he is.

Heck...Clark's list is shorter and he's not suppose to be a as clever as Bruce???

 

[jono11]

Are you trying to get on my nerves?

Nope, I just happen to have been confused by you, and then amused by your perspective. See, identity-related mindwipes don't have a great history in the DCU. There was that one time with Wally West, and then, gosh, it seems like there was another one that happened...

 

[jono11]

Geeez.........for a guy who dresses in black, wears a cowl, hides in shadows, only comes out at night, lurks in shadows, lives on the outside of town and works in a cave, a whole lot of people (enemies included) know who he is.

Heck...Clark's list is shorter and he's not suppose to be a as clever as Bruce???

Out of 6 billion people, he's doing pretty well.

 

[dude stannis]

No, he's not. celldog is completely right way too many people knows Batman's identity.

 

[Nepenthes]

Yeah this is bullshiiit. Batman wouldn't stand it. He would find some horrible way to make them forget.

 

[dude stannis]

They had the chance to do it in Crisis, but no, because they're idiots.

EDIT: Blind Justice is still in continuity. Knightfall never stated that Bruce hadn't been in a wheel chair before, in Blind Justice Alfred stated that the Batcave was nevr designed for wheelchair access. In Knightfall that point wasn't raised. Besides, his stint in a wheelchair was because he woke up from a coma, not because he got shot, so it was temporary, where as in Knightfall the risk was permanant.

 

[Ultimate_Superman]

I don't think I heard about this one. Can you tell me a specific story that showed that Ma and Pa Kent definitely know that Batman's real name is Bruce? (You see, in the second draft that I'm almost ready to post, I'm sticking in notes on just when a person learned the secret, or demonstrated that he had already known for awhile, or whatever. To make the list more accurate and helpful.)

JLA 0 Ma Kent knew. In The Death of Superman they knew and in Superman's Wedding they knew. Also They knew in the lastest AC that comes out on the 22nd.

 

[jono11]

JLA 0 is a possible future, and I refuse to believe that any of those count yet. Because they don't yet.

Hasn't a lot from the Death/Rebirth of Superman been retconned?

Where in Superman's Wedding?

How do you know what they thought in an issue that hasn't been published yet?

 

[Ultimate_Superman]

JLA 0 is a possible future, and I refuse to believe that any of those count yet. Because they don't yet.

Hasn't a lot from the Death/Rebirth of Superman been retconned?

Where in Superman's Wedding?

How do you know what they thought in an issue that hasn't been published yet?

Preview.

 

[Harlekin]

The whole bit with the Society of Villains learning the heroes' identities was not a retcon. It was the revival of an old obscure JL story.

Anyway, Ma Kent certainly didn't know, although maybe she does now, but I recall her saying in a recent issue how after Clark helped her out that "Batman probably never does this for his parents." That'd be a pretty cold and heartless thing to say if she knew he was Bruce Wayne.

 

[dr.strange]

dude love has a point.its to the point now like who doesnt know? he should mindwipe everyone except supes,wonderwoman ,robin and nitewing.and for the last time,how can gordon not know?if hes such a great cop. i remember him sorta put up a theory in batman;year one.so much for a secret id.anyone of these people could screw him over.of course its up to the writers.

 

[dude stannis]

My guess is Gordon, eventually put two and two together, but kept it to himself.

But it really is rediculous. Something has to be done.

 

[Fenryr]

Alfred Pennyworth (Different versions have been told of how he learned, but either he was already working for Bruce when the Batman identity was created, or else he was hired later and quickly found out)

I've always preferred the idea that Alfred helped Bruce become Batman ala Batman Begins. It makes sense that he'd be in on it from the very beginning, since he's a surrogate father of sorts.

Also, whether or not is was retconned at the end of the arc, there was a time when "Cosmic King", "Lightning Lord", and "Saturn Queen" all knew Bruce's identity, and Clark's. But, since the entire arc dealt with alternate timelines, it's not clear if they still know or not, or whether they were even the real Legionnaires. (Superman/Batman 13-18)

 

[Memphis Slim]

Geeez.........for a guy who dresses in black, wears a cowl, hides in shadows, only comes out at night, lurks in shadows, lives on the outside of town and works in a cave, a whole lot of people (enemies included) know who he is.

Heck...Clark's list is shorter and he's not suppose to be a as clever as Bruce???

Wow......this guy has a point! Bats is suppose to be the the "mysterious" guy. But there ain't much mystery when that many people know you.

And that "compared to 6 billion" argument don't fly. In Bruce's line of work just six people knowing can be too many.

 

[Memphis Slim]

They had the chance to do it in Crisis, but no, because they're idiots.

EDIT: Blind Justice is still in continuity. Knightfall never stated that Bruce hadn't been in a wheel chair before, in Blind Justice Alfred stated that the Batcave was nevr designed for wheelchair access. In Knightfall that point wasn't raised. Besides, his stint in a wheelchair was because he woke up from a coma, not because he got shot, so it was temporary, where as in Knightfall the risk was permanant.

Another great point! Crisis could have been a whole new jumping off point for his I.D. being clean again.

 

[DarkSpider04]

When did the Joker find out? My understanding of it, as a hardcore Batfan, is that he's come close before but always chooses not to take the opportunity to reveal because it wouldn't be right, would shatter the myth, and like you say, his problem's not with a secret identity but with the public one.

Batman: Death of the Family
Joker told Batman he knows who he is, but it was never revealed if the Joker was telling the truth.

Batman: Endgame / Joker: Endgame
While on the phone with Jim, the Joker interrupted with "Hello Bruce" after punching Jim out. The arc ended with a huge battle that left Bruce to ditch the Bat suit.

The following arcs was with Jim as the Batman. Bruce returns as Batman just before the start of the DC rebirth.

Then there's Joke's War.