The Amazing Spider-Man 2 Who would win a fight?

[Spidey-Lad93]

Who would win a fight between Toby Maguire(Spider-Man) and Andrew Garfield(Spider-Man) if you had to chose one. By the way this isn't a who played the better Spider-Man thread

 

[UltimateWebhead]

 

[webhead731]

They both have the same powers. The only advantage Tobey's has is infinite webbing.

 

[Andrew Lucas]

Why i feel this soon will become a Raimi vs Webb thread??

On topic Garfield wins lol

 

[JOE]

I think Garfield cause he's taller, longer reach. Just kidding, pointless thread dude...

 

[melvintwj]

In terms of...

Strength:
I feel that Toby's Spider-Man is stronger based on what we've seen so far.

Skills:
Andrew's Spider-Man has more/better spider-like movements. Also able to make good use of his surrounding.

Agility:
Andrew's Spider-Man seems to be more agile and quicker.

Powers:
Andrew's Spider-Man has webshooter. Can't really tell if the webbing is stronger than Toby's. Though Andrew's is more "steel"-like and Toby's is kinda gooey. 50-50 on that.
The intensity of Andrew's spider-sense seems to be stronger. (He detected danger at the bridge from Gwen's roof.)

That's all that I can think of now, and I'm gonna give it to Andrew.

Edit: Come on guys I think it can be a fun thread if we are willingly to share our opinions without bashing anyone

 

[webhead731]

It's a little unfair to judge their fighting style considering a lot of the fighting in ASM was all CGI and more advanced than 2001ish/2002, 2003/2004, and 2005-2007 when the last series was being worked on. They couldn't do everything they wanted. I really liked Andrew's movements etc but I can't imagine that being pulled off 10 years ago.

 

[JayTee]

Andrew Garfield's Peter can actually build stuff. So he'd make a device that zeros in on the frequency of Tobey's tear ducts and make him cry uncontrollably, then knock him out. While making jokes.

 

[Andrew Lucas]

In terms of...

Strength:
I feel that Toby's Spider-Man is stronger based on what we've seen so far.

Skills:
Andrew's Spider-Man has more/better spider-like movements. Also able to make good use of his surrounding.

Agility:
Andrew's Spider-Man seems to be more agile and quicker.

Powers:
Andrew's Spider-Man has webshooter. Can't really tell if the webbing is stronger than Toby's. Though Andrew's is more "steel"-like and Toby's is kinda gooey. 50-50 on that.
The intensity of Andrew's spider-sense seems to be stronger. (He detected danger at the bridge from Gwen's roof.)

That's all that I can think of now, and I'm gonna give it to Andrew.

Edit: Come on guys I think it can be a fun thread if we are willingly to share our opinions without bashing anyone

Good points

Andrew wins then.

 

[Angryfantasyfan]

Didn't this happen in a Superman movie?

I know, lets make it a tag team fight. Each Spider-Man partnering with his Uncle Ben.

 

[Spidey220987]

Didn't this happen in a Superman movie?

I know, lets make it a tag team fight. Each Spider-Man partnering with his Uncle Ben.

Then The Amazing Spider-Man wins, because Uncle Sheen knows a right cross when he sees one! PLUS he hasn't been on his ass for 35 years LOL!

 

[melvintwj]

Laundry Sheriff's got Andrew Spidey's back too hahaha!