Tron Bonne
All Ass, No Sass
- Joined
- May 24, 2007
- Messages
- 33,289
- Reaction score
- 1
- Points
- 31
All right, what's ignorant about it?
I've watched anime. Good anime, bad anime. I've tried to understand it. I've tried to "get" it. I've tried to like it. But it keeps getting lost in translation again and again and again. Please enlighten me about what exactly I got wrong about the generic description. What, exactly, is it that you anime fans love about the genre beyond the fact that geek chic tells you you're *supposed* to love anime? Because I can't ever see it as anything more than cookie-cutter one-size-fits-all Japanese attempts to try to take everything they can from American and Japanese pop culture and mash-up the hell out of it into some bizarre smorgasbord of incomprehensible nonsense.
Seriously, enlighten me. I've been trying to figure out what anime is all about for decades now, and nobody's given me a straight answer yet.
Generalizations tend to be pretty ignorant by default. It's like someone saying, "All American movies are extremely violent and try to be overly masculine." And I have seen people make that statement. And I think it's fair to say that anyone who knows even the slightest thing about that will just kind of shake their head and dismiss it. That's not to say there might be something to that generalization, since every corner of the world has their little niches as far as entertainment goes (There are a lot of mainstream American movies that are overly violent and stupidly masculine, after all), but only those with totally closed minds would ever actually subscribe to that kind of mentality. I don't think anyone can 'enlighten' those who have no real wish for enlightenment, and that's definitely the vibe I get from everything you've posted about it. From apparently only thinking anyone likes it because some "geek chic" told them to (which I find is probably a new one) to calling it a genre (animation is not a genre, it's a medium, as the highest praised Brad Bird will tell you). I mean, you know, if you've never found a single thing you like, that's just been your experience, and I won't denounce you or anything like some, but when this topic often comes up, I tend to find it's more of a case of not really looking, and not really looking with an open mind to begin with. But you know, like I said, if that's how you've seen it, then that's just how it is. I doubt I, or anyone else, could say anything to convince you otherwise.
Last edited: