Homecoming Who is YOUR Peter Parker/Spider-Man

[spider-neil]

Very simple it's 3 picks;

Number 1.
The **** the haters choice.
Forget the short list, age appropriate, gender appropriate, time period appropriate. If you choose ANYONE to play Spider-Man who would it be.
State the age you want them to be when they play the role?


Number 2.
The shortlist choice.
Who do you want to play Peter the from the final six?

Number 3.
The, NO! PLEASE NOOOOOO!!! Choice.
Who is you're absolute worse, world crashing down, disastrous, boycott the movie if chosen, choice?

 

[spider-neil]

I'll be first

1. Josh Keaton - 16 years old

2. Asa Butterfield

3. Dylan O'Brien

 

[Web-Head]

Michael J. Fox
Holland/Rowe
Jaden Smith

Can't really think of one on the top of my head for choice 3

 

[BatsDC]

1 - Dylan O'Brien

2 - Asa Butterfield

3 - Chandler Riggs or Charlie Plummer

 

[Daedalus]

1 - Tommy Wiseau

2 - Charlie Rowe

3 - Asa Butterfield

 

[NotSoLongAgo]

1. Dylan O'Brien

2. Dylan O'Brien

3. Everyone on the list but Holland and Rowe

 

[SyntaxError]

1. Anton Yelchin

2. Charlie Rowe

3. Dylan O'Brien, Ansel Elgort, Logan Lerman

 

[DavidW]

Dylan O'Brien

Charlie Rowe

Anyone who looks like a fetus

 

[harryoscop]

1. Dylan O'Brien

2. Charlie Plummer

3. Liam Aiken

 

[Godzillasaurus]

1. Andrew Garfield (has to finish what he started)

2. Charlie Rowe

3. The kid from Modern Family (wasn't he a very early pick?)

 

[Shikamaru]

EDIT: Misread the OP.

1. David Henrie (same age he was during Wizards; normally I'd say Garfield but the reboot needs a new face)
2. Asa Butterfield
3. Jaden Smith

 

[WBwins]

1.Dylan O brien.
2.Tom Holland.
3.Justin Bieber

 

[PeterBenParker]

1. Vincent Martella/Freddie Highmore (18 for both)
2. Charlie Plummer
3. Ansel Elgort, Dylan O'Brien, and Nat Wolff

 

[RivenSky]

1. Dylan O'Brien
2. Charlie Rowe
3. Asa Butterfield

 

[Shanio1]

1.Donald Glover (Early 20s)
2.Asa
3.Chanler Riggs

 

[Airwings]

1. Leonardo DiCaprio back in 1998. But it's only one of many dream picks I have

2. From the list: BUTTERCREAM

3. Dylan zero Brien was the worst, now it's either Plummer or Judah

 

[zizzy]

1. Tony Revolori
2. Charlie Rowe
3. Ansel Elgort/Dylan Sprayberry

 

[X Knight]

can't speak for #1.

#2. Charlie Rowe
#3. Asa Butterfield

 

[theinfernoman]

#1. Andrew Garfield "early 20's" or a young Michael J. Fox.
#2. Tom Holland or Charlie Plummer.
#3. Daily Bugle Spidey.

 

[Shutdowncorner9]

1. Dylan O Brien

2. Andrew Garfeild(lol i dont wanna choose a shortlist actor... maybe Rowe...)

3. Judah Lewis

 

[Webhead2006]

Ideally it would have been nice to see andrew and reboot spidey but keep him somehow.

But if not I would have liked to see dylan Obrien. I thought he would have been a good pick.

But if we go by the current crop of names I would go with tom holland. Right now he seems to be the one I think work best.

So 1. Andrew Garfield
2. Holland
3. Asa/lintz/lewis

 

[DOBSON10]

1. Dylan O'Brien
2. Charlie Rowe
3. Pretty much all of them except Rowe

That's based on having to pick someone new. I would have kept Andrew Garfield, he was excellent.

 

[Green Goblin]

Garfield again or Logan Lerman

 

[SM71]

1. Nick Robinson/Tye Sheridan

2. Charlie Rowe

3. Asa Butterfield/Charlie Plummer

 

[Indy Flash]

Andrew Garfield should've finished it.