Better Batman Fight Scene: Warehouse (BvS) vs SWAT Fight (TDK)

[Spider-Aziz]

Is it though? I feel the swat scene is much better to look at. The colors in the warehouse scene is overdone to the point of ugly, just like most Snyder scenes. The swat scene has very pleasant lighting.

I like the colors and lighting in both scenes.

 

[Spider-Fan]

The warehouse scene I think looks better in several regards and Batman in action looks more like the Batman I picture from comics. That said, the SWAT fight has better story and tension within the scene itself. Therefore it is vastly superior.

 

[Kahran Ramsus]

The SWAT scene was interesting and inventive with Batman trying to assess a tricky situation, find out who the actual villains are, and try to non-lethally take down an innocent invading force that are fooled into targeting innocent hostages. It is both clever and fun. Batman has always been at his best when he is forced to use both his athleticism AND his brain.

The Warehouse scene was like watching someone else play Arkham Asylum. Why do that when I can pick up a controller myself?

 

[LvtLeeTDK]

The Warehouse scene was like watching someone else play Arkham Asylum. Why do that when I can pick up a controller myself?

Why watch porn when you can go have sex ?

 

[ernesth100]

I'll give it to the warehouse scene. It hit way harder and more brutal. The SWAT fight felt kinda cartoony and extra. But the warehouse scene was pure fighting magic.

 

[Mandon Knight]

Why watch porn when you can go have sex ?

Not everyone can have 'instant sex'.

 

[Kevin Roegele]

Christopher Nolan has many strengths, but fight scenes aren't one of them.

The warehouse fight was the Batman fight scene we'd been waiting to see for eight movies.

 

[Kahran Ramsus]

Why watch porn when you can go have sex ?

Because porn is a lot easier and more accessible at any given time. Sex is often not an option. The difference in effort between picking up a video game controller and picking up a remote control is negligible.

 

[unholyrevenger]

People dissing the warehouse fight for being brainless, and praising the Swat scene for batman's intelligence. Swat scene isn't intelligent it's just making the mooks and Swat team idiots to play up the hero, a-la Superman 2 where Zod and Co. stand around while Supes saves people.

 

[FunkMiller]

People dissing the warehouse fight for being brainless, and praising the Swat scene for batman's intelligence. Swat scene isn't intelligent it's just making the mooks and Swat team idiots to play up the hero, a-la Superman 2 where Zod and Co. stand around while Supes saves people.

This makes no sense. Please rewrite with some decent grammar, otherwise I can’t argue your point.

 

[Mandon Knight]

Regards the above, I understand what is being said and a reply to that is perfectly 'do-able'.

 

[OutOfBoose]

Warehouse. Outside unnecessary killing and brutality, this is Batman action I want to see in future films. Yes, it won't compensate for inferior character work, but it looks more impressive.

I said it many times, but I don't like Batman action in TDK trilogy. Relying on camera tricks and ******ness of opponents doesn't do it for me.

 

[The Joker]

People dissing the warehouse fight for being brainless, and praising the Swat scene for batman's intelligence. Swat scene isn't intelligent it's just making the mooks and Swat team idiots to play up the hero, a-la Superman 2 where Zod and Co. stand around while Supes saves people.

This makes about as much sense as your claim that people want Superman to be like Donald Trump; http://forums.superherohype.com/showpost.php?p=36485957&postcount=893