FeedOnATreeFrog
(A Metal Gear reference)
- Joined
- Sep 17, 2012
- Messages
- 6,339
- Reaction score
- 576
- Points
- 73
If we could only get Raimi's Spidey 4, TASM3, or another MCU Spidey 4, which would you pick?
I think the window for a fourth Raimi Spider-Man is closed. I could not picture that cast wanting to come back for a whole film, and I think the Garfield series deserves it more, tbh.
But seriously though... why not all three?
We need an ASM 3 and a Tom Holland Spider-Man 4...
I agree.
Tom Holland, bless him, deserves a 2-3 year break from playing Spider-Man. NWH left his character in a good if tenuous spot -- which gives the studios an opportunity to utilize Garfield and Maguire again.
I know people have been quite optimistic about the future with how NWH left off, it didn't have the same effect on me.
But i don't think Tobey came out of NWH as the most interesting out of the 3. I think Nostalgia might have clouded alot of views on the build up to the movie when everyone thought he would automatically be the stand-out.
I don't know if I'd agree. I haven't seen much disappointment or anything regarding Maguire's Peter.
I think Garfield had a great reception because of the redemption that was baked into his return, both in a meta sense (he gets to be in something not terrible) and in the story itself (he gets to save the girl this time). In a strange twist, the failure of TASM gave Garfield's Peter more to work with, and more to pay off with his return.
I disagree. I remember someone, before the films release saying that the concern was that it would feel like Toby and Tom and Andrew would be just be the one no one cared about. And funny enough he probably got 2 of the biggest crowd moments in the film. one from his entrance, which helps if you already knew who he was. And the other his redemption, which for the reaction to really work you would have to have some emotional connection to what his redemption is for. aka people wanted Andrew to save MJ and redeem himself for the death of gwen from TASM2. it wasn't about redemption from films you might feel are bad.
And then Andrew won the critics choice award for NWH. and Many argued it should have been Tom because he was the main character and had the most emotional scenes.