I’d like an adaptation of Joe Kelly’s JLA story where the lasso of truth breaks because Diana cannot accept its answer. The world spins in to chaos when the truth no longer has meaning.
Maybe tie it to Greg Rucka’s Hiketeia where Diana is honor-bound to watch over a young girl after she incites the Ancient Greek ritual. It’s a story of Diana further facing truth & justice, but also the grim reality of fate (personified by The Fates themselves). There’s something about this girl’s case that she cannot accept.
Diana, to fix this conundrum, seeks the guidance of her mother & Themiscrya and so she needs Cheetah’s help since she can no longer find the island herself. Cheetah, in the 40 years since WW84, has become obsessed with the occult and especially Amazonian history so she can try to undo her curse. Diana has been keeping tabs on her old friend, guilt-ridden by how far gone she is, and offers Cheetah the chance to bathe in the lights of the Purple Ray—believing that it’ll cure her of the enchantment.
But we later find out that Cheetah is working with Veronica Cale, who seeks Paradise Island to raid its resources & profit from its wonders. Cale would have been previously introduced in the film as an ally to the modern-day Wonder Woman (perhaps she updates her invisible jet so that it’s user-friendly?)
Cale in actuality is Paula von Gunther, revealed in Act 3. She was a WWII nurse shipwrecked and washed upon Themiscrya’s shores while Diana was already in man’s world. Queen Hippolyta, inspired by her daughter, helps Paula and heals her under the Purple Ray before sending her back to man’s world. The Purple Ray gave Paula Amazonian strength & longer life, but she always resented the queen for casting her out and “cursing” her to a plain existence back in man’s world. So she builds herself into Veronica Cale and makes an empire for decades before construing a plot to have her revenge on Hippolyta and the Amazons.
Of course, one such part of Cale/Gunther’s plot was the framing of the innocent supplicant under Diana’s care—perhaps she was brainwashed by Doctor Psycho, which thus introduces the conundrum (and sets Diana on the path back to Themiscrya for the villains to follow). Yes, the actions were done by the girl but they were not her own. She’s guilty and innocent at the same time.
Diana learns that there are many truths in this world—and we must open our minds and our hearts to accept them all as one universal truth. Love lol or wonder, or some such.
The end of the film would be Veronica Cale convincing military partners that the source of the global chaos is from emitting from Themiscrya, igniting a war between man & Amazon. In the midst of battle, Diana is able to share her truths/lessons with the sparring parties, & negotiates peace. In the end, Themiscrya too learns there are many truths—and man is not all bad—and Diana is installed as their ambassador in the United Nations, finally opening their borders to man’s world after millennia of isolation.