Finally got around to seeing this last
The bad - The movie lacked a lot of good transition scenes, star wars in every movie so far has had scenes that transition from place to place and often showed us the landscape, creatures, before switching to a new area. It was definitely shot differently than other star wars films, and in that sense, didn't feel very star wars like.
L3 was obviously a huge miss, not sure whose rights they were going for, and the scene with Emilia and her talking about Lando was incredibly forced and just bad.
The forced inclusion of Maul - although this could have been a new narrative, I'd much have preferred to see Jabba, and saved maul for a different story (Yes I know much of his story is told within TCW and Rebels, but I love seeing maul on the big screen..just didnt make sense for Han to deal with him.)
Qira shouldn't have been so posh, I just couldnt buy into emilia's character mainly because the look wasn't right (not on emilia.)
I get that the trilogy was supposed to lead Han to the point we see him in episode 4, but this movie just stands to hurt his character, i also dont like they try and make him seem heroic.
Now, the good -
It was a genuinely good movie. Fun ride, and despite my dislike for Han in comparison, it was no where near as atrocious as they did with Luke in TLJ, it was an acceptable level.
The action scenes were fun - and overall I could get into the characters, I would have liked a sequel, and thing they can only stand to improve on this one.
Its probably in the same vein as rogue one, right now, its slightly better, given that I havent been able to get through rogue one, I think I could watch this one again in a year, but probably wont just because well nobody else will say "Lets watch that again!". But at least its not in the TLJ category of "we aren't watching that."