• We experienced a brief downtime due to a Xenforo server configuration update. This was an attempt to limit bot traffic. They have rolled back and the site is now operating normally. Apologies for the inconvinience.

Amy Adams IS Lois Lane

Status
Not open for further replies.
Don't get me wrong. I like Lois. And she's DNA if we're talking about the Superman mythos. But I don't like the character as a person. If Lois Lane were a real person then I'd probably try to **** her sister Lucy just to infuriate her.

Edit: She reminds me of every clichéd cheerleader archetype there is. Clark's the nerd who gets shoved into lockers for carrying her books while she doesn't even notice him. She only begins to notice Clark after college when he invents some piece of technology that earns him billions and sleeps her way into becoming Clark's trophy wife.

Edit x2: Amy Adams, Zack Snyder, and David Goyer are honestly the first people that have gotten me to appreciate the character.
 
Last edited:
That's not Lois at all if you get the character mate. And certainly that's not Amy version of the character which some never talk about.

I mean I want to know what Lois has been up to when JL start's. How is she coping? Is she working her ass off an trying to keep everything in check? Is she hitting the bottle?
 
That's not Lois at all if you get the character mate. And certainly thats' not Amy version of the character which some never talk about.

I mean I want to know what Lois has been upto when JL start's. How is she coping? Is she working her ass off an trying to keep everything in check? Is she hitting the bottle?

I edited. Amy's version is basically the first version I've liked.
 
Honestly i've had enough. Some people did the same with Amy's MOS thread. Never talked about what her arc /role might be in that movie.

It happened again in her BvS thread. No one talked about her arc/role in that movie. When BvS got delayed some even talked about her getting re cast. :funny:

Same thing happening here in her JL thread. Hardly anyone want's to talk about what she might be up to in the movie. I'm here for that.

I mean I want to know what Lois has been up to when JL start's. How is she coping? Is she working her ass off trying to keep everything in check? Is she hitting the bottle?
 
I was speaking to the preferences of the writers themselves who have spoken openly about their affection for the Lois/Superman romance. Also, to be clear, I said nothing about these creators supporting a Superman/Lois marriage. These creators like the Superman/Lois romance in its many forms. Morrison, for example, prefers Superman and Lois explored through the triangle-for-two. But it doesn't matter if these two are constantly dancing around each other or happily ever after. The vast majority of Superman creators prefer Lois Lane as Superman's love interest. Finally, again, I have to reiterate that I am not asking you to alter your preferences. However, in your previous post, you suggested that preferring Superman/Lois was a mark of imperfection.

In my opinion yeah, but it's just my opinion.

Clark was a spineless coward. What else do you call a man who allows his date to be sexually harassed by a mobster? Clark understood Lois's criticism of his alter ego and cheered her on when she fought back.

Action-Comics-1-Lois-Lane.jpg

Didn't say he wasn't but so bluntly calling him out on it is rude IMO, she could've simply walked off without speaking to him, which would've served to highlight her distaste of him just as effectively.

That's all she did? If that's all she did, then all she did was save Superman because that is what the headline reads. And, once again, Lois wasn't marginalized in the Silver Age. She was so popular that she appeared in all of the regular Superman comics in addition to having a top-selling title of her own! Lois shined many times throughout the Silver Age.

Yeah that's all she did! She appeared regularly but in a marginal capacity and she added nothing to the story.

Lois Lane's role in comics was dictated and limited by the her cultural milieu. If stories emphasized romance and marriage, it was because that was how society constrained women in the 1960s. But Lois still pushed against those limits by not only working in a male-dominated profession, but also by demanding respect and moving away from the domestic sphere to expand her skills or take risks for the sake of justice. By the 1970s, Lois had evolved along with the women's movement. Lois Lane's trajectory in comics is something that should be celebrated for representing the role of women in society from the 1930s to today.

Doesn't change the fact that all she did was needing to be rescued and trying to nab superman, totally useless.


Rampant idiocy?! Not only was Lois constantly trying to prove Clark was Superman because Superman's efforts to put her off the idea never worked (hence the repeated attempts), but we're talking about Lois posing a genuine challenge to Superman. The lengths he had to go to in order to introduce some doubt into Lois's mind were extensive. I'd hardly say that it was rare to see Lois playing more than a love interest or damsel role. I've found enough examples in my reading of her sharing information, making sacrifices, and kicking butt to know that Lois was just as likely to be seen making a difference as she was seen rescued or romancing Superman.

Yeah rampant idiocy is right, when her life's mission (apart from trying to marry superman) was to expose him and she still couldn't prove that superman and clark are one and the same despite the fact that she interacts with both on a regular basis.
And she wasn't a challenge to superman, she was merely a welcomed distraction nothing more.

I'm still not convinced you are as knowledgeable as you say you are based on your misrepresentations of the canon and history of the character. Your insistence that Lois Lane was marginalized during the Silver Age is a particularly egregious example.

Could careless if you're convinced or not, lois was marginalized and useless in the silver age and you'd realize it too if you weren't wearing your fan-girl tinted glasses but you won't so again I could careless about convincing you.

I idolize Lois because during the Silver and Bronze Age the character was limited by the men who wrote her and patriarchal society in which she existed. During the same time, Wonder Woman's characterization also took a dramatic nose dive. Diana lost her powers, which caused feminists like Gloria Steinem to cry out in outrage. Silver Age Wonder Woman was apologetic about her powers because her power made Steve Trevor insecure. Marriage was a common topic in Wonder Woman stories of that time as well. I idolize women, like Lois and Diana, who were both constrained by the patriarchal chains of the post-war era, and who were

that's what I'm saying Lois was limited character with little characterization and I never delved into the why of it, just the fact that she was, so thanks for supporting my point.

both ultimately able to emerge out of that time empowered by celebrating their own unique strengths and capacity to make a positive difference in the world.

Let's not get carried away here, these are comicbook characters that make the world alittle more tolerable but that's it. You want an example of women who make a true difference in the world then think mother Teresa or madam currie but I digress...


So a version of Superman who was completely alienated from Lois and his supporting cast, spent most of his time as Superman, and was in love with Wonder Woman fell victim to poor writing that rendered him uninteresting? I agree. Superman always suffers from poor writing when his core mythology is tampered with beyond repair.

Had nothing to do with his alienation from lois but rather the shabby writing and the convoluted, linked story lines that went nowhere. Morrison's action comics run was good because it was self contained and so was Snyder's unchained and some of Greg pak's stand alone arcs (and the batman/superman stuff) were pretty solid IMO.

And if the changes they made were intended to solve the problem, then what they realized from their experiment was THEY WERE WRONG.

Again due to bad writing nothing more.


The fact that Lois needing physical help from time to time negates any good the character does in other ways is proof of your sexism.

From "time to time" LOL!! She is a walking damsel she was an insult to feminists everywhere.

Empowerment has nothing to do with physical power and physical strength. Needing to be rescued does not make a woman less than a man or even less than a physically stronger woman. Lois is an admirable character and a vital agent of change in the Superman mythology because she represents ways in which humanity can make a difference without special abilities or extraordinary physical gifts. Any reasonable Superman fan should have gotten that message by now because it is the very core of what he represents as a hero.

No lois is important for the superman mythology because she's the love interest, the "girlfriend", after all wasn't that the title of her "best selling series" as you put it.


Of course it's all fiction! Fiction reflects who we are and what we value. If you value Wonder Woman as a feminist icon, then you must also value Lois Lane as a feminist icon. Because what makes Wonder Woman a feminist icon is what would make the character admire and appreciate Lois Lane. Feminist icons like Gloria Steinem and Mary Tyler Moore were both journalists who used journalism in real life and in fiction to empower women and reshape society
.

Ok then.

To disregard Lois as a feminist icon because she experienced the same struggles of the women of her era and experienced the same empowerment as women of her era is nonsensical and hypocritical. To argue that Lois Lane cannot be a feminist icon because she is not physically capable of saving herself is anti-feminist because gender equality has nothing to do with physical equality.

The concept of lois lane is iconic, her portrayal in a large amount of story lines isn't.


There's nothing to make up. You literally could not support a Superman and Wonder Woman romance without putting Lois down. In fact, you just did it again. By arguing that Diana is "more deserving," you are arguing that her compatibility with Superman is defined by how she measures up to Lois Lane. How can I help drawing the conclusion I drew when you cannot stop yourself from being so transparent in your reasoning?!

Calm down seriously, You're gonna have an aneurysm. I don't need to support anything, I like the superman/WW pairing and that's all there is to it.
As for putting lois down, well I can't help it if the character is often written as a joke.
 
Superchan, I made a new home for our discussion. When I do respond, I'll respond to you there, because I don't think this type of conversation is welcome here anymore. As I promised, though...

15482366.gif


Honestly i've had enough. Some people did the same with Amy's MOS thread. Never talked about what her arc /role might be in that movie.

It happened again in her BvS thread. No one talked about her arc/role in that movie. When BvS got delayed some even talked about her getting re cast. :funny:

Same thing happening here in her JL thread. Hardly anyone want's to talk about what she might be up to in the movie. I'm here for that.

I agree. Let's focus on celebrating the past and anticipating the future.

I'm actually fascinated by what Lois' role in Justice League could be. Every movie so far has made sure to give her something journalistic to do, so I'm hoping the same is true here. I definitely want Lois to interact with more than just Martha and Clark, and I'd love if she could help people figure out something important. I'd even love if we got a sense that she's been keeping an eye on Lex.

I don't expect her role to be huge, but I do expect her to be an important element that helps to develop Superman in terms of his impact on her and on the world prior to his return. I also expect an emotional reunion.
 
Superchan, I made a new home for our discussion. When I do respond, I'll respond to you there, because I don't think this type of conversation is welcome here anymore. As I promised, though...

15482366.gif




I agree. Let's focus on celebrating the past and anticipating the future.

I'm actually fascinated by what Lois' role in Justice League could be. Every movie so far has made sure to give her something journalistic to do, so I'm hoping the same is true here. I definitely want Lois to interact with more than just Martha and Clark, and I'd love if she could help people figure out something important. I'd even love if we got a sense that she's been keeping an eye on Lex.

I don't expect her role to be huge, but I do expect her to be an important element that helps to develop Superman in terms of his impact on her and on the world prior to his return. I also expect an emotional reunion.

What she's doing needn't be journalistic, it could be entirely focused around her dealing with Clark's and her subsequent importance in preventing the Knightmare from happening. So I'd like some Martha Kent, Lois scenes.
 
It should be journalistic as well. That's first and foremost what she is. And the good thing is about her arcs in MOS and BvS is that she has had those.

I hope she's keeping tabs on Lex too. Maybe she's a foreign journalist again? Loved that they showed Lois in Nairomi in BvS. Maybe she could be in Gotham or Khandaq? The Rock Black Adam rumours?
icon10.gif
 
Matter of fact, I'd really like to know how will Lois factor into this film. I'm curious about her state of mind since Superman's death, as well... is she still fully committed journalist at DP or is she on a leave, curled on a sofa, watching Netflix, with empty wine bottles all around her (it was a joke, before misslane accuses me of picturing Lois as a depressed alcoholic and bites my head off :p). What interests me the most is whether they're going to keep "Lois is the key" plot? I mean, they can't ditch it altogether, despite some changes probably being done.
 
It should be journalistic as well. That's first and foremost what she is. And the good thing is about her arcs in MOS and BvS is that she has had those.

I hope she's keeping tabs on Lex too. Maybe she's a foreign journalist again? Loved that they showed Lois in Nairomi in BvS. Maybe she could be in Gotham or Khandaq? The Rock Black Adam rumours?

I feel like journalism is so important to her character that it would be a shame to not get any sense of that with her in this next installment of her journey. I like the idea of her being in the field. Something like that wouldn't have to be indicative of a whole arc in the movie, but it could just establish that she's out there pressing on, so to speak. I know that in the original Death of Superman arc, Lois did some investigating of rumors of Superman's return. In the Superman: Doomsday animated film, which was based on Death of Superman, she investigates Lex whose company is creating clones.

tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso4_r1_250.gif
tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso3_250.gif

tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso7_r1_250.gif
tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso5_250.gif

tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso6_250.gif
tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso1_250.gif

tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso9_r1_250.gif
tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso2_250.gif

tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso10_250.gif
tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso8_250.gif


Maybe we'll get something like that?
 
Matter of fact, I'd really like to know how will Lois factor into this film. I'm curious about her state of mind since Superman's death, as well... is she still fully committed journalist at DP or

I don't think Lois will abandon journalism. In fact, it is more likely she'd use work as a distraction. This Lois doesn't seem like she's the type to wallow for long, but she does take some time off to brood a bit before jumping back into the fire.

is she on a leave, curled on a sofa, watching Netflix, with empty wine bottles all around her (it was a joke, before misslane accuses me of picturing Lois as a depressed alcoholic and bites my head off :p).

Why would this bother me? Lois Lane has done this. What you've described is very Lois Lane. Maybe not the wine part, but Lois definitely has a wallowing streak. Both Teri's and Erica's Lois Lanes have overindulged during tough times (their comfort food is chocolate and ice cream!). Erica's Lois was bummed about her ex, Oliver Queen, standing her up for a birthday ritual of beer pong, so she watched a Jaws movie marathon while gorging on snacks and doing her laundry. She also got drunk at her cousin's engagement party because of her own romantic woes. Lois Lane is not immune to wallowing.

tumblr_ne0cilJOII1rahtsio2_250.gif


What interests me the most is whether they're going to keep "Lois is the key" plot? I mean, they can't ditch it altogether, despite some changes probably being done.

I think they'll keep it, but I can't say if it'll be exactly what may have been originally intended. She may investigate key information or just be a spiritual touchstone for Clark that brings him back from some kind of liminal state (loss of memory, loss of control of his mind, the afterlife, etc.).
 
This is the "Justice League" forum, and the topic of this thread is "Amy Adams IS Lois Lane." That means the discussion should stick to Amy Adams' role as Lois Lane in the Justice League film. If you want to discuss other portrayals of this character or compare the Lois Lanes we've gotten throughout the years, I think that new thread misslane38 created sounds like a wonderful place to do so. Let's get keep this one on track, please.

I will start deleting posts if this does not happen.
:yay:
 
I don't think Lois will abandon journalism. In fact, it is more likely she'd use work as a distraction. This Lois doesn't seem like she's the type to wallow for long, but she does take some time off to brood a bit before jumping back into the fire.

Yeah, that seems more likely to me. Besides, some time will surely pass between the end of BvS and beginning of JL, anyway.

Why would this bother me? Lois Lane has done this. What you've described is very Lois Lane. Maybe not the wine part, but Lois definitely has a wallowing streak. Both Teri's and Erica's Lois Lanes have overindulged during tough times (their comfort food is chocolate and ice cream!). Erica's Lois was bummed about her ex, Oliver Queen, standing her up for a birthday ritual of beer pong, so she watched a Jaws movie marathon while gorging on snacks and doing her laundry. She also got drunk at her cousin's engagement party because of her own romantic woes. Lois Lane is not immune to wallowing.

tumblr_ne0cilJOII1rahtsio2_250.gif

I was just taking the piss, as I tend to do this quite a bit, referring to your passionate stance when it comes to her character and a possibility of me being on a wrong side of it. No disrespect meant. Still, I am glad that you're not a Green Lantern fan. See? It's just the way I tick. :woot:

Anyway, I actually really liked that scene from BvS: UE when she unpacks blooded clothes from Nairomi incident and grasps for a glass of wine to help her calm her nerves. It seemed like a very human reaction. Hell, I've never been in an African shootout and I can still relate. :oldrazz:

I think they'll keep it, but I can't say if it'll be exactly what may have been originally intended. She may investigate key information or just be a spiritual touchstone for Clark that brings him back from some kind of liminal state (loss of memory, loss of control of his mind, the afterlife, etc.).

I also think they have to keep it. What comes to mind is the fact that Lois is probably the only one who knows about codex being part of Supes, so she might figure out the means to his resurrection through the codex, somehow.
 
Last edited:
Don't get me wrong. I like Lois. And she's DNA if we're talking about the Superman mythos. But I don't like the character as a person. If Lois Lane were a real person then I'd probably try to **** her sister Lucy just to infuriate her.

Edit: She reminds me of every clichéd cheerleader archetype there is. Clark's the nerd who gets shoved into lockers for carrying her books while she doesn't even notice him. She only begins to notice Clark after college when he invents some piece of technology that earns him billions and sleeps her way into becoming Clark's trophy wife.

Edit x2: Amy Adams, Zack Snyder, and David Goyer are honestly the first people that have gotten me to appreciate the character.

Well you have to remember, Lois was originally based on a girl who the creator had a crush on but she ignored him? I think thats the coldness of Lois, but with Lois, I normally saw it that she ignored Clark/ people, sometimes because she got way ahead of herself very often, not that she was snobbish/stuck up.

She was also based on Torchy Blane who was a fast reporter in the 30s. That was the original idea for Lois. Lois was a career/city woman and Clark is a farm/small town man.

I like the more modern era backstory for Lois where shes the generals daughter. It explains some of her tough edges and determination in all things. Especially Smallville where it is explicitly stated that she was dragged around by her dad to loads of different army bases over the years.

I do see what you're saying that if Lois were a real person in life, she'd be difficult to get along with. I think if you don't like tough, career people you may not like her, but she does often show people skills in her characterizations.

I think more than anything else, just like with Superman, neither of them would probably even have time to socialise with anyone really, because they're always chasing down the truth. Thats why they're fascinating characters to watch.

I'd never see her as a cliche cheerleader or goldigger character though.
 
The main issue is there just isn't time to develop some new journalistic side story among all the other things they need to do. The only Journalistic thing I could think of that wouldn't be obtrusive would be to make her part of the missing scientists thread, but that's about it.
 
I feel like journalism is so important to her character that it would be a shame to not get any sense of that with her in this next installment of her journey. I like the idea of her being in the field. Something like that wouldn't have to be indicative of a whole arc in the movie, but it could just establish that she's out there pressing on, so to speak. I know that in the original Death of Superman arc, Lois did some investigating of rumors of Superman's return. In the Superman: Doomsday animated film, which was based on Death of Superman, she investigates Lex whose company is creating clones.

tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso3_250.gif

tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso7_r1_250.gif
tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso5_250.gif

tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso6_250.gif
tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso1_250.gif

tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso9_r1_250.gif
tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso2_250.gif

tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso10_250.gif
tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso8_250.gif


Maybe we'll get something like that?

Yep that would've be good. But Lex is stuck in Arkham Asylum.
icon10.gif


The main issue is there just isn't time to develop some new journalistic side story among all the other things they need to do. The only Journalistic thing I could think of that wouldn't be obtrusive would be to make her part of the missing scientists thread, but that's about it.

Fine by me. That would've been my next guess.
 
I feel like journalism is so important to her character that it would be a shame to not get any sense of that with her in this next installment of her journey. I like the idea of her being in the field. Something like that wouldn't have to be indicative of a whole arc in the movie, but it could just establish that she's out there pressing on, so to speak. I know that in the original Death of Superman arc, Lois did some investigating of rumors of Superman's return. In the Superman: Doomsday animated film, which was based on Death of Superman, she investigates Lex whose company is creating clones.

tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso4_r1_250.gif
tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso3_250.gif

tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso7_r1_250.gif
tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso5_250.gif

tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso6_250.gif
tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso1_250.gif

tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso9_r1_250.gif
tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso2_250.gif

tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso10_250.gif
tumblr_n0suj1WRbO1qgb3zso8_250.gif


Maybe we'll get something like that?

That's nice and all, but this movie isn't just the return of Superman, it is also Justice League and Justice League is the more important of the two so deference should be given to that.

*Also it was so dumb and immature of Superman in Superman: Doomsday to at that stage in his relationship with Lois to still be trying to put on his front and the fact that she let him get away with that is equally egregious.
 
Last edited:
Happy to see Amy in a Superbowl ad. She's a huge football fan.

All the names in the ad are famous people. It really shows that Amy is a popular movie star. :ilv:
 
Guys, what do you think will happen to Amy's Lois Lane? I keep hearing rumors they will kill off the character. I think she has a smaller role in JL1 comparing to BvS. But what about JL2? Even a smaller role than JL1?

Are we ever going to see a MOS2? I wish they can make a low to mid budget solo Lois Lane film where she investigates murders, etc. It would be a cool if a they make a solo thriller about Lois.

Imagine a standalone Lois Lane movie written by Arrival script writer and directed by Denis Villeneuve!
 
That's nice and all, but this movie isn't just the return of Superman, it is also Justice League and Justice League is the more important of the two so deference should be given to that.

Hence the use of the term "something like" in my post. The idea would be to adapt the elements that organically fit a JL story (i.e. the reunion), and to maybe use bits and pieces. I wasn't suggesting 1:1 verisimilitude. There's no need to overreact, condescend, or be argumentative.

*Also that was so dumb and immature of Superman in that movie to at that stage in his relationship with her to still be trying to put on the front and the fact that she let him get away with that is equally egregious.

Yep.
 
You've been hearing from who?

Amy said she's doing both JL in the BvS press junkets and in the Arrival press junket said she's up for doing MOS2. In fact shes' the one who confirmed it's in some kind of development. If she wasn't involved she'd straight up say I'm not in it.
 
^ Ooops sorry flickchick. I quite like how Lois is different in each version shes in. I think Amy varies quite alot from the personality & looks of the prototype of Lois. But I know they were going for something different.
 
You've been hearing from who?

Amy said she's doing both JL in the BvS press junkets and in the Arrival press junket said she's up for doing MOS2. In fact shes' the one who confirmed it's in some kind of development. If she wasn't involved she'd straight up say I'm not in it.


Reposting again since you can't read.

Guys, what do you think will happen to Amy's Lois Lane? I keep hearing rumors they will kill off the character. I think she has a smaller role in JL1 comparing to BvS. But what about JL2? Even a smaller role than JL1?

Are we ever going to see a MOS2? I wish they can make a low to mid budget solo Lois Lane film where she investigates murders, etc. It would be a cool if a they make a solo thriller about Lois.

Imagine a standalone Lois Lane movie written by Arrival script writer and directed by Denis Villeneuve!
 
"I keep hearing rumours" From who? there's no who would no such thing this early unless they're the film makers or Amy herself. The only source is the woman herself. Who said she's doing both. Well she's already filmed JL and during Arrival's press junket said she's up for doing MOS2.

That's all we know.

And Denis Villeneuve is too good for this current DCEU.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"