NotSoLongAgo
#spidermansolit
- Joined
- Nov 29, 2009
- Messages
- 7,154
- Reaction score
- 13
- Points
- 58
Everyone's always talking up the Cornell theme and I thought it was just so-so
Everyone's always talking up the Cornell theme and I thought it was just so-so
I think it would be wise to withhold final judgement until we've seen it with the title credits and in the context of the pre-title sequence. Context matters.
Eh, I don't necessarily agree. Name me one Bond song that wasn't that great that was made better by the context of the opening credits.
Nah. This was released as a single, completely divorced from any film or visual elements and can be judged as such.
Have you heard the new Low album, theres a duet on there that might be the finest duet I've heard in my whole life.
Haven't heard it. Is it available anywhere?
Sam Smith's song is boring.
I'll listen to nothing but Explosions In The Sky, Sigur Rós, El Ten Eleven and never get bored.
He only has four minutes and yet there is nothing interesting, intriguing, or inventive.
Hell, Max Richter just made an 8 hour album called Sleep and I never got bored during that, because he had flourishes and creative things he did...
You're not an idiot. I WISH I could do a 180 on the song, but it's not happening.Welp.
I always try to own up when I feel I've been wrong about something, so I'm admitting that I've done a total 180 on the song. I don't love it, I would still put Skyfall and You Know My Name ahead of it, but I do really like it.
Clearly I'm an idiot. Please disregard everything I say in the future.
I like the sparse quality of the song as it evokes the emotional longing of the melody as it does Smith's vulnerable and fragile vocal performance.
I don't get the "boring" complaints. Ryan Adams new cover album of Swift's 1989, now THAT is boring hollowness.
Give me a great intro sequence to "Writing's on the Wall" and it has the potential to be a really great, both elegant and emotional experience.
That's the final international trailer. They are sometimes shorter than American trailers. I expect the final US trailer to be 2 minutes at least.
I feel like strings about being vulnerability should an emotional trip from fragile to being strong, and I don't Smith makes that clear enough in the song. He kinda flatlines at being vulnerable.
Dude, Adele has more guts and machismo in 'Skyfall' than Smith. I don't want to get into that debate about masculinity but damn. There are comments made by women who even thought the same thing. Where's the bravado? It's Bond.
Emotional longing, vulnerability, fragility. That's completely the wrong thing to be associated with Bond. It definitely has those qualities which is why it doesn't sound like a Bond song but more like a female character singing a ballad in a musical. Or if not a female character, then a male one from something like Les Mis.
Does anyone really imagine Bond singing something like Bring Him Home?