I understand people not wanting to shell out full price for a game, if they don't think the upgrade is substantial enough.
But I bought TLOU Remastered in 2014, and while I appreciated the improvements, I still felt very aware that it was graphical upgrades slapped on top of the original. Still enjoyed it, but I think most people would have to admit, you can always feel the difference a little compared to a from the ground up remake.
Now, 8 years later, I get the chance to play a fantastic game again but have it feel almost brand new again? Sure, I immediately see the value in that.
Again, I understand if this product isn't for everyone, but still think there's maybe some selective memory going on. Like, we have seen some absolutely garbage, rushed out the door and make money fast "Remasters" in the last 5 or so years, from huge companies that should know better. Like what the hell was AC 2 Ezio edition from Ubisoft? Or Rockstars GTA collection?
When I look at the minimum effort most companies put into this stuff, I will happily pay the money to be able to play one of the best games of the last decade in the best possible quality.
And as for the timing, Sony isn't stupid. They have an upcoming, huge budget TV show that is going to multiply their audience massively. It's a smart move to have an up to date edition, for their newest console, that also rolls straight into TLOU 2. If you've owned 2 versions of this game already, and this one doesn't do anything for you, then the product probably isn't for you anyway, so what's the issue?