I remember very well the day Spider-Man first came out on the silver screen. I convinced my mother to let me skip school that day, wasn't hard cause I was always the kind of child who could miss 4 days of school and still get every question right on the test, and before the movie we went to Toys R' Us where I promptly bought the entire first wave of figures before seeing the movie. It was a wonderful day capped off by a wonderful movie. It is one of my favorite movie going experiences of my life and a memory I value greatly.
But that all said, though I have lots of nostalgia for that day, the prospect of seeing a multiverse Spider-Man film with all the previous characters returning isn't one I was all that excited about. While I love the old Tobey movies, a movie isn't great because of fan service. You still need a great story, compelling characters, etc. This movie was going to live and die based on its own merits, not by digging up memories of the past. Fortunately for me, this succeeds at far more than being a nostalgia tour.
When it comes to our MCU Spider-Man, I have enjoyed both of Holland's prior films quite a bit. I love him in the role, the villains were aces, and seeing Spider-Man interact with the broader Marvel world was great. But all that did come at the expense of several things I love about the character. Prior to No Way Home, it just felt too easy for Peter. We didn't see the balance of his 2 lives causing that many issues for him, at least not in ways Holland's Peter much cared about. That changed with this movie. No Way Home is the MCU's best representation of Spider-Man by far. Peter has a ton of issues caused by his mistakes in this film, and it costs his loved ones as well. You can relate to his decision to ease that burden on everyone else, and when it all goes wrong, Peter very much has to deal with the fallout of his own actions. There isn't a Tony Stark here to fall back on, and it is like the film went out of its way to reintroduce these core Spider-Man struggles. I am very happy they did this. It is the heart of the film and really what makes this film work so well
What is going to get the most attention though is the more gimmicky multiverse stuff. I will be frank and say I don't have any nostalgia for either film in The Amazing Spider-Man series. I was especially irked when I found out we would be seeing the return of Electro, who frankly made me cringe almost every scene he was in when we last saw him. Thankfully, we saw less cake boy here and basically just let Jamie Foxx play himself. I wouldn't call Electro a great villain in this, but he didn't make me want to pour beer in my eyes and ears at least. That is an upgrade. Lizard and Sandman are just basically here. They are around quite a bit, but are mostly just CG characters most of their screen time and just fill out the roster.
It should surprise no one that the 2 stand out villains were also 2 of the most beloved: Alfred Molina's Doc Ock and Dafoe's Green Goblin. I was nervous about Ock in this one. Spider-Man 2 is still the undisputed master of the franchise for me, and Ock's redemption at the end is wonderful. But it also more or less turned him good. So seeing him as a villain had me worried he was regressing as a character. While Molina's Ock is handled with a bit more comedy in a few scenes than I would like, he absolutely stays true to what we say in his last outing. It was wonderful to see. But the MVP of the villains in this movie is Willem Dafoe as the Goblin. Simply put, he is just amazing and hasn't missed a beat at all. He is every bit as fun and menacing as ever in this film, and pretty brutal as well. He steals the show every scene he is in. All in all, the villains work.
But what everyone came to see was the team-up. Let me start with Andrew Garfield. I disliked his movies, and I found his version of Parker mostly unlikable in those movies. He screwed around too much in dangerous situations, felt more like an attempt to appeal to the YA crowd than be Peter Parker, and I just wasn't into his version of the character. That said, this appearance was easily his best in the role. The unlikable elements that rubbed me the wrong way are stripped out of here, and instead we get some great Spider-Man speeches imparting wisdom to the younger Tom Holland continuing where his previous movie had left him. I actually liked him here. But I am a Tobey Maguire guy, so naturally I was more interested in his use. I think the movie did him justice as well. He too gets to impart wisdom upon Tom Holland, and it is a much better send off for the character than his last outing was. Seeing the 3 interact was also a lot of fun, and you can see the actors had a wonderful time with it. That fun was definitely infectious.
I had many reservations entering this movie: Would the fan service overshadow everything else? Would this feel like a Spider-Man story? Would this kind of lose the plot and story? Would this do justice for Tom Holland's Spider-Man and be HIS story? Thankfully this movie passes on all fronts. It is an MCU film though, so expect the usual humor now and again and the various MCUisms for lack of a better word. This is a darker story than the prior 2 Spider-Man films though, and has a lot more emotion behind it. This juggles being both a conclusion to the Tom Holland Home Trilogy as well as a celebration of the Spider-Man franchise as a whole at the same time. While I think Spider-Man 2 and Spider-Man: Into the Spiderverse are still your kings of the franchise, this is one of the better entries in the franchise and definitely Tom Holland's best outing. It also sets up Tom Holland's story pretty well for future success, and I am excited about the direction they seem to be taking him for future movies.
5 out of 5
On a final note, the 1st post credits scene with Eddie Brock going back to his world further confuses me on how this proposed Hardy and Holland eventual crossover will go. Sort of nonsensical to just, send him to the MCU in his movie, then boot him back immediately. Yeah, it leaves the potential there for a black suit story, but it is still a major WTF are we doing here from a story standpoint.