Babillygunn
New Age Outlaw
- Joined
- Nov 26, 2014
- Messages
- 5,201
- Reaction score
- 7,248
- Points
- 118
I like the concept if done right. And while CW has had a pretty rough track record, it has given us Superman & Lois, Arrow seasons 1 and 2, Stargirl season 2, and Flash season 1.
So it hasn’t been 100% awful. In fact, when it works, the shows are great. Let’s face it, Superman & Lois is certainly the best version of those characters since Donner’s, and in many ways, I’d even go so far as to say it is superior.
All that said, I would love this concept if it had a comics accurate Dick Grayson (unlike the moody version that we’ve seen in Titans), as well as Barbara, Stephanie, Cass, Damien, and Jason. I would love that line up. I’d also love to see Jean Paul Valley and Clayface in recurring roles as allies.
But seeing as how they seem to be giving top billing to Harper Row…she may be the most uninteresting character that Scott Snyder ever created. And let’s face it: other than Court of Owls and maybe Jim Gordon Jr, Snyder doesn’t have a great track record of original characters. Then they shoe-horn Carrie Kelly in a move that makes no sense. Seeing those two characters makes any interest in the show, which has great promise as a Dick/Barbara led show, absolutely plummet.
So it hasn’t been 100% awful. In fact, when it works, the shows are great. Let’s face it, Superman & Lois is certainly the best version of those characters since Donner’s, and in many ways, I’d even go so far as to say it is superior.
All that said, I would love this concept if it had a comics accurate Dick Grayson (unlike the moody version that we’ve seen in Titans), as well as Barbara, Stephanie, Cass, Damien, and Jason. I would love that line up. I’d also love to see Jean Paul Valley and Clayface in recurring roles as allies.
But seeing as how they seem to be giving top billing to Harper Row…she may be the most uninteresting character that Scott Snyder ever created. And let’s face it: other than Court of Owls and maybe Jim Gordon Jr, Snyder doesn’t have a great track record of original characters. Then they shoe-horn Carrie Kelly in a move that makes no sense. Seeing those two characters makes any interest in the show, which has great promise as a Dick/Barbara led show, absolutely plummet.